Field Notes vs Rhodia: Which Notebook is Better for Everyday Carry?

When it comes to everyday carry (EDC) notebooks, two names consistently rise to the top: Field Notes and Rhodia. Both are beloved by writers, note-takers, and outdoor enthusiasts for their portability and quality. But which one is truly better for your daily scribbles, sketches, and lists? In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences between these two iconic notebooks to help you make an informed choice.

Whether you're jotting down camping gear lists, recording field observations, or simply capturing fleeting thoughts, the right notebook can make a world of difference. We'll examine paper quality, durability, size, and value, and also touch on how accessories like a sturdy cover or a reliable pen can enhance your experience. By the end, you'll know exactly which notebook deserves a spot in your pocket or pack.

Paper Quality and Writing Experience

The heart of any notebook is its paper. Field Notes uses 50# premium paper, which is thick enough to resist most inks but may show slight ghosting with heavy markers. It has a slightly rough, tactile finish that many find satisfying for pencil and ballpoint pens. On the other hand, Rhodia uses 80 gsm Clairefontaine paper, known for its exceptional smoothness and resistance to bleed-through. This makes Rhodia a favorite among fountain pen users.

For everyday carry, the writing experience is subjective. If you prefer a bit of tooth and grip, Field Notes offers that classic, utilitarian feel. If you favor a silky-smooth surface that lets your pen glide effortlessly, Rhodia is hard to beat. Both papers are acid-free and archival quality, so your notes will stand the test of time.

• Field Notes: 50# paper, slight tooth, good for pencil and ballpoint.
• Rhodia: 80 gsm Clairefontaine, ultra-smooth, excellent for fountain pens.
• Both are acid-free and archival.

Durability and Build Quality

Durability is crucial for an EDC notebook that gets tossed into backpacks, pockets, or glove compartments. Field Notes notebooks feature a sturdy chipboard cover with a distinctive kraft or colored finish. They are designed to withstand rough handling, and the binding is sturdy enough for frequent flipping. However, the paper can be prone to tearing if you're rough with it.

Rhodia notebooks come with either a flexible cardstock cover or a rigid back, depending on the model. The staple-bound or spiral-bound options are robust, and the paper is more resistant to tearing. Rhodia's covers also have a sleek, professional look that many appreciate in a work or travel setting.

• Field Notes: chipboard cover, rugged, but paper may tear under stress.
• Rhodia: flexible or rigid covers, more tear-resistant paper.
• Both can handle daily use, but Rhodia edges out in paper strength.

Size and Portability

Size matters when you're carrying a notebook every day. Field Notes are famously 3.5 x 5.5 inches, perfectly sized for a back pocket or a dedicated notebook sleeve. They fit neatly into most EDC organizers and are unobtrusive. Rhodia also offers a similar pocket size (3.5 x 5.5 inches) in their staple-bound line, so portability is comparable.

However, Field Notes has a slight edge in terms of thickness options: you can choose from 48 pages or 96 pages, allowing you to customize how much bulk you want. Rhodia typically offers 48 pages in their pocket notebooks. For those who want a bit more writing space, Rhodia also provides larger sizes like A5, which are great for desk use but less pocket-friendly.

• Field Notes: 3.5 x 5.5 inches, 48 or 96 pages.
• Rhodia: same pocket size, usually 48 pages; also available in A5.
• Both are pocket-friendly, but Field Notes offers more page count options.

Price and Value

Price is often a deciding factor. Field Notes are typically sold in 3-packs, which can be a better value if you go through notebooks quickly. Individually, they cost around $10-$12 for a 3-pack, making them about $3.50 per notebook. Rhodia pocket notebooks are usually sold individually for around $5-$7, or in multi-packs that bring the price down slightly.

When considering value, think about how you use the notebook. If you're a prolific note-taker who fills pages daily, the lower per-notebook cost of Field Notes might be more appealing. If you prefer a premium writing experience and are willing to pay a bit more, Rhodia's paper quality could justify the price. Also, consider that you can protect your investment with a durable cover, like a leather sleeve, which works with both brands.

• Field Notes: ~$10 for a 3-pack, ~$3.50 each.
• Rhodia: ~$5-$7 for a single pocket notebook.
• Field Notes offers better per-unit value; Rhodia offers premium paper.

Style and Customization

Your notebook is an extension of your personality. Field Notes is famous for its ever-changing limited edition covers, from vibrant colors to unique patterns. This makes it a fun collectible and allows you to express your style. They also offer a range of inside page options, including dot grid, ruled, and plain paper, so you can pick what suits your needs.

Rhodia, on the other hand, tends to stick with a classic, minimalist design: orange or black covers with a simple logo. While they offer a few variations, the focus is on functionality over flair. If you're someone who loves to stand out, Field Notes might be more appealing. If you prefer a timeless, understated look, Rhodia delivers.

• Field Notes: limited editions, multiple page formats (dot grid, ruled, plain).
• Rhodia: classic orange/black covers, fewer design options.
• Field Notes offers more variety for personalization.

Everyday Carry Considerations

When choosing an EDC notebook, think about how it will integrate with your gear. If you use a field bag or a dedicated notebook cover, both brands fit standard sizes. Pairing your notebook with a reliable pen is essential; a ballpoint or gel pen works well on both papers, but fountain pen users should lean toward Rhodia for the smoothest experience.

You might also want to consider accessories like a sturdy cover to protect your notebook from the elements. While Field Notes and Rhodia are both durable, a cover can extend their life. Additionally, if you're an outdoor enthusiast, you might appreciate a notebook that can handle a bit of moisture; neither is waterproof, but both are reasonably resistant to splashes.

• Both fit standard EDC covers and sleeves.
• Fountain pen users should choose Rhodia for less bleed.
• Consider a protective cover for outdoor adventures.

Field Notes vs Rhodia: The Verdict

So, which notebook is better for everyday carry? The answer depends on your priorities. If you value a rugged, customizable notebook with a lower per-unit cost and a touch of personality, Field Notes is the clear winner. Its compact size and variety of page options make it a versatile choice for jotting down ideas, lists, and sketches on the go.

If you prioritize a luxurious writing experience with the smoothest paper and superior bleed resistance, Rhodia is the better pick. It's ideal for those who use fountain pens or simply appreciate the feel of high-quality paper. Both are excellent, but your personal preferences will guide you.

• Choose Field Notes for affordability, variety, and ruggedness.
• Choose Rhodia for premium paper and smooth writing.
• Either way, you'll have a reliable EDC companion.

Ultimately, both Field Notes and Rhodia are top-tier choices for everyday carry notebooks. If you're leaning toward Field Notes, you'll love the variety and value. But don't forget to pair your notebook with quality accessories, like a durable cover or a reliable pen, to make the most of your note-taking experience. And if you're in the market for a new notebook, consider checking out our collection of Field Notes products, including the FIELD NOTES - PLAIN PAPER (3 PACK), which offers a clean canvas for your thoughts.